Which side do you prefer?
Right, if it weren't for that editing. Outlines just look better than full-color eyes, unless the bangs only cover less than half of the eye, and from the top. I'm all for differing styles, though; that's what make adaptations fun.
Hate people who say "the book was better" or really anything that means "I'm upset that the story presented isn't exactly like the source material right down to the visual depiction!"
Hidden eye is always sexiest.
Like these hidden hands.
What is she doing to that little girl? Use your imaginations.