Why is Gilgamesh chaotic good?
Shouldn't he be Chaotic Evil, since he wants earth to be destroyed from Holy Grail?
He wants to wipe out the extras. That just happens to be the vast majority of mankind.
I certainly wouldn't call him Good in FSN, but Gil's alignment will always be contended.
Saber is so weak because her master is shit. She was indeed much stronger in fate/zero. Same goes for gilgamesh.
Stats kinda' make sense as the noble phantasm stat is the most important one, anything else is not that important unless they're fighting in close quarters.
Stats don't make sense in Zero.
I mean Kariya gives Lancelot nearly the same stats that HERAKLES gets from Ilya.
Waver somehow gives Iskander good stats while being a completly shit tier magus.
Kerrytugu somehow gives Saber 2 stats higher than Rin!Saber that's confirmed to be maxed out in stats in CM3.
>he wants earth destroyed
Why are you so bad at reading anon? He clearly explains it to Shinji. Very clearly.
If there is 1000 units of mana on Earth, humanity has to share those 1000 units of mana. Meaning only a few people will ever hold close to a unit of mana. And with 7 billion people, its very little.
On the top of that, the lands are tamed, the beasts are weak, the heroes are almost non existing, food is stable.
Gil had to rule, in a land where his 5 servants was indispensable. If they died, it could take a generation for there to be enough surplus for Gil to have more servants.
HERK is stat capped in Fate/Stay/Night. Thats his issue. On the top of that, Ilya is practically a retard, carring the Einzbern greatest potential for combat tactics.
While Lancelot needs to use his stat boosting blade + berserker bonus to reach the stat cap.
Waver makes sense. Alexander would have higher stats with Fastwheels. No, seriously. And a smaller restriction on NP usage.
Now, for Kerry its retarded.
>Waver makes sense.
Shirou is a better magus and has more circuits than Waver
>While Lancelot needs to use his stat boosting blade + berserker bonus to reach the stat cap.
There's something very wrong when fucking KARIYA can get Lancelot to those stats
Also the fact that Lancelot is as strong as herakles
Gil is a grade A surgeon who saved Illya's life. He's obviously good.
Shirou isn't inbreed enough to be trained in how to circulate and speed up prana regeneration.
Shirou is like somebody wearing crippling gear, but once he takes it off, he is a star athlete. He goes from barely being able to stump on, step by step; To being able to compete for the world records in kilometer springs.
And read my post. Lancelot isn't as strong as Herc, but Herc is stat capped. He can't get more STR, because the Fujuki Grail System do not scale beyond A, and A+ with modifers.
Lancelot scales up to his legend, almost. Herc is sitting there at 10-20% of his real power, because being stat capped is a bitch.
>Lifts the fucking SKY
>Famed for wresting with gigantic hellspawn
>Most famed weapon is a BOW, the GODWEAPON of STR
>Kills the shit out of monsters famed for speed and endurance
Waver is 1st generation of inbreeding anon.
He is trained to recover Prana.
Shirou has more magic circuits than the average magus.
The alignment is a big problem though.
>He is trained to recover Prana.
Literaly noone in his family before him ever did anything with magecraft.
>Shouldn't he be Chaotic Evil, since he wants earth to be destroyed from Holy Grail?
Find out his reasons. If he thinks the people f the world will be better off dead, then good. If he thinks he will gain, then evil. If he's bored, then neutral.
Those mental gymnastics don't work. All three fit, anyway. He does think those people are better off dead (which is certainly not inherently Good), he does gain from creating circumstances wherein he can rule, and he is oftentimes bored (not necessarily Neutral, either).
But it doesn't even matter with his phantasm being at this level.
by the way,does anyone have this
with the gilgamesh and kotomine edit?
it's a holdover from the original Light novel prototype of fate/stay night that nasu made in high school before it morphed into what we got in F/SN.
that gigamesh wasn't gonna be the total dickwad we saw in F/SN
You're lucky I'm in a good mood
I'd recommend you to read it.
The only god he ever opposed was Ishtar when she threw a bitchfit.
And please elaborate on "freeing mankind" because the gods had to create Enkidu when Gil was too much of an asshole to his suspects
If Gilgamesh told jokes he would be Gigglemesh
Holy shit my sides.