new one piece thread /a/, post your best penguins
The real docking formation.
Oda can no longer write memorable panels with emotional impacts. If it was written today, it would have had a full cluttered background of Jaya, a closeup on Teach's face, and a reaction from the crew.
He lost his mastery of subtly and simplicity.
Everyone remember to do your best to appreciate Penguin today!
It's hard to choose a best Penguin when there are so many good pictures of him...I've always liked this picture though
reminder that zoro could have single highhandedly taken on doffy.
So if I'm estimating right, Gear Fourth should be revealed in about 10 episodes? Before Valentines Day for sure.
do you think ace will be brought up in wano? since he's been there before, I'm sure he told some guys about luffy
When will Soul King's fans round up to join Luffy's cause? Surely his songs were full of subliminal messages.
>only one of them will be able to marry Paulie
Nah. He uses the no background effect pretty well when he needs to.
Reminder that Zoro is best bro. Screw the powerlevelfags and baiters.
Well Luffy's sandals pop in and out of existence after he tosses them away so he probably just goes off memory. Also don't like how the blood on Doffy's mouth in that panel looks, it looks like he had a lot of spaghetti inbetween scenes.
The U.S, gladly claims Nami and her rack.
Her physical evolution from the early chapters to now is incredible. Oda just went for it.
Do you guys think Law will finally crack a smile and be laid back when he's back with his crew or will he keep scowling
>tfw u dressed up as Ace for Halloween and everyone thought u were a gay cowboy
haven't had a chance to post this before, but it's pretty cute.
I hope they'll hug him, that would be cute.
Back in the day people really bought into Law's Doctor of Death moniker, and the story presented him as a little more edgy. Granted, Sachi, Penguin and Bepo were still silly, but it was more understated since they were sharing screentime with a dozen other characters. It doesn't fit at all now that we see what they're normally like.
What are the chances kaidou's zoan animal is a tardigrade or "water bear"
>microscopic worms famous for being indestructable
>can survive between 150C and 1K (one degree above absolute zero)
>pressure between the vacuum of space and 1200 atmospheres
>dehydration to 3% water content for 10 years, up to 120 frozen
>1000 times the radiation needed to kill a human
>also aquatic, so they can't drown
He's almost certainly tried drowning since he sunk ships he was imprisoned on, of course he could just wash up on shore or get saved by island wales or something. Maybe he tried eating a second devil fruit but dropped it and didn't manage to pick it up off the ground in under five seconds
I wonder if One Piece was told from any other character's perspective, if people would have thought that Luffy was actually a 6 meter tall giant.
(Plus the whole thing with Robin sinking the ships, seriously peeps need to stop listening to rumors)
>Dressing up as One Piece characters for Halloween.
Yeah, normies won't know who you are. That's why I wore my Jabura costume and just told everyone I was a "kung fu werewolf."
>Monkeys and dogs are archenemies
How does that happen? Dogs and cats being archenemies makes sense, since they're both companion animals and dogs like to chase cats. But dogs and monkeys? You don't really see those animals together (unless you do in Japan for some reason?). It doesn't seem like a common enough thing for a theme to develop between them.
I think you're just thinking of that one anime where dogs and monkeys hate eachother because one made it to space before the other did
there are hot spring monkeys in japan so they're bound to interlace with dogs in some areas
What are some other movies besides Zatoichi that are worth watching from the other actors? I admit I have never really delved into Japanese films beyond Godzilla, Seven Samurai and Yojimbo
goddammit I can HEAR him making that drawn out 'ooooooooh~?' just from looking at this picture
>I think you're just thinking of that one anime where dogs and monkeys hate eachother because one made it to space before the other did
Medabots was a good anime, but it's a cultural thing in japan.
I wonder if fishmen are welcome on Zou
>Las Vegas casinos
We already had some in Alabasta.
ButI would be lying if I said that I wouldn't want to see Nami empty out the casino by first playing, and then steal the rest afterwards
Jaya = Old West
Shandora = El Dorado/South American Pre-Columbian Civilizations
Shandia = Native American Tribes
West Blue = Old West
Banaro = Old West
Whiskey Peak = Old West
Rain Dinners = Luxor Hotel (Las Vegas)
Sabaody = Caribbean
>implying colonization did anything other than benefit the niggers
>implying niggers slaves in america weren't treated better than they ever own their afric na shitholes
>Implying there is anything wrong with rape
>Implying most women don't enjoy being raped
well shit, doesnt Japan usually portray USA as Texas?
I really hope Oda DOESNT do that... but I can already see the blonde-haired, blue-eyed, cowgirl Nami clone
how many people do you think have died from zou's gigant shits falling onto them? or from running ashore onto his poopy islands and drowning or becoming stranded in his filth? think about it his stinky droppings must have quite the death toll over all these years. and that's just counting people not all the poor sea life that has suffered from zou's fecal offerings to the ocean gods. and just imagine the smell. if you have ever been to a zoo and sniffed the pungent aroma of elephant dookie just imagine that like times a million! his poo poo and his pee pee are a mystery that must be explored imo
also can you fathom how big zou's weewee is? elephant's have huge dongs so one the size of zou must be scraping the bottom of the ocean. i think you could track his movement over the years even if there were no footprints just by tracking the deep gouges scarring the ocean floor from his dangling dingaling. does elephants have big hangning balls? this too is a mystery that ust be explored
What if the minks just harvest the shit for resources?
They could collect it fresh from source (think of its as a stinky mining operation) or anchor the floating shit island to one of the legs and carry it up over time till the turd is gone.
Theres a lot of vegetation on the elephants back after all and all that stuff needs nutrients.
What was the point of timeskip if Kizaru still can solo Strawhat crew no-diff?
I know it won't happen but I really want to see a big bad be taken down by Zoro, even if it's a strong enemy but turns out to be like a mini-boss compared to the OP world at large.
damn,wiper was one strong mofo, he had more stamina than zoro back then.
with haki he could be a big ally, i wonder if he is stronger than sanji now
He was Luffy's equal. I hope we get another Wiper-like character in the future.
Didn't they have kairouseki on Skypiea? I can't remember the exact circumstances, but I think there was some and I kept thinking as a kid why they didn't just put it on Enel while he was resurrecting himself.
Also, where did they get kairouseki?
Yes, they did.
Who knows. Shandians were very knowledgable about Devil Fruits.
Oh right, silly me.
I would be less surprised about it if they didn't give it the same name, considering they have a different term for haki. This implies the concept of kairouseki is known for atleast 400 years.
The scene of her caring so much for the climbing dragon, and mourning his death, is foreshadowing to the death of Monkey D. Dragon, which Robin as a close friend of his will mourn.
Her caring for the dragon Momonosuke is similar foreshadowing.
But he was using the kairouseki in his gun, not the dial itself.
If we're following the "Devil Fruits were the spirits in the trees" theory, definitely. Shandians know some shit.
It's because Luffy shamed him. Law tried to fulfill Corazon's dream (stop Mingo) and failed, and when he was about to be given the sweet release, Luffy interfered. Law's pride was destroyed.
>be giant elephant
>1000 years old
>just strolling along and minding your own buisness
>some wierd mamals live on your back
>they start climbing in your ass and mining shit
>the shit actualy pooped out is tied to your legs
>they smear your shit on your back to plant stuff
>literaly walkign for hundrets if not thousand years with your own shit on your back
beeing Zou is suffering
Sure but that isn't how it is spelled.
Franky is worse, and Ace?
.. well you can't really ruin perfection now can you?
I haven't thought about Wiper in a long time. It would be cool if he returned somehow, but I think his destiny is in the clouds.
Maybe he'll come back when everyone who Luffy has made friends with in the past, journey to help him.
He's a beast, though. I'd ship him with Nami.
you dont belong here. Leave now before Socio-kun gets his hands on you
like, when im in these threads i like to think about what you guys were arguing about each arc.
Its always been a show i really liked and these threads change it, good and bad
>i like to think about what you guys were arguing about each arc.
here's something new to digest
I win a LOT of arguments here on wiki knowledge alone. I talked some moron down about Rouge the other day when I havent even gotten to whatever is after Arlong Park
Here's something new to digest, i dont care
i always think people will get tired of arguing but its incredible to think you guys have been doing it for years
its more like i never had an opinion before, now i hate sanji
to be fair, im probably the only one that does it
>its more like i never had an opinion before, now i hate sanji
>forming opinions because of shitposting memes
you really are retarded aren't you
see like, dont you get tired of replying and thinking everyone you dont agree with is a shitposter? ever think i hate sanji because i hate feminists and anyone that treats girls as if theyre fragile flowers or something
you guys try to prove opinions wrong, how do you even do that
Because most of the sanji hate here comes from one shitposting faggot that memes a copypasta.
> ever think i hate sanji because i hate feminists and anyone that treats girls as if theyre fragile flowers or something
also you stated yourself, you flying faggot
>>its more like i never had an opinion before, now i hate sanji
You never had an opinion before but now you hate him because of posts on /a/ of all places
still mad about Rouge not needing a dick, are we?
well Mihawk didnt whoop him immediately, probably but who knows now
I AM reading it, just slowly. I go through youtube and the anime to fill in the gaps.
also OP is a big series with an active fandom and lots of hot dudes that get fanart
>I never had an opinion before
>ever think i hate sanji because
unconfirmed spoilers from 2ch
- cover is luffy's hometown
- usopp brings in his banana boat, while the crocodile Luffy is riding with Wanda just swims in the flood
- Sanji's group was described as 'dead' because they had their souls stolen from "the god of Whale forest" when they entered there at night...
- Jack apparently ate the "dream dream DF" and destroyed the town using one of his attacks that "steels the consciousness"....
jack's fruit sounds really stupid but i hope it has some connection with "voices"
i think youre missing the point.
also yeah i mean i never cared about sanji. but then someone said whos youre favorite SH. then i realized who my least favorite was. Go ahead try and change mymind
>never had an opinion before
>not that i dont have any now
lets try an be less autistic next time bb
I havent even gotten to Dressrosa yet. I came in during Punk Hazard
>still mad about Rouge not needing a dick, are we?
I don't even know what the the fuck you're talking about. Or wait, are you the faggot arguing about how Rouge having a D was shoehorned in?
>They still call him that in the official translation.
Steven, translator of OP for Viz, fucking hates that they call him that and pretty much everybody working on the manga says they would change it back if they could (along with Portgaz) and if they can reprint the whole manga in the future, probably will.
>but then someone said whos youre favorite SH. then i realized who my least favorite was.
Nice damage control. Nigga go reread our conversation and see if this excuse makes any sense.
that wasnt the original point which I think was that Rouge didnt need a D at all but had one
The original assertion being that NO D. has been shoehorned in. Not even taking Saul into account
I'm sure he's going to forget that Saul said this again
and yet all you had to defend Rouge with was circular reasoning when it isnt actualy something to get in a fight about?
gotta wonder why you fight so hard to defend a fictional character's value
Because shitposters like you think you win these shitty arguments if you get the last post in and then boast about it later when all you did was make yourself look like a retarded faggot.
Taking all bets!
Brook used spooky magic to put them into a death like state.
Chopper used medicine to put them in a death like state.
Sanji used hormone cooking to put them in a death like state.
nah, that argument literally started going in circles when I asked WHY Ace even needed a D. in his name when Sengoku would point it out either way
really seemed to set alot of you off. After that, it was an endless stream of Ace because Rouge because Ace because Rouge
Shoehorn should be added to the new greek meme after Zou is over desu.
>when I asked WHY Ace even needed a D.
And a lot of people answered you. Niggas just had to keep repeating themselves because you seem to be a little brain dead and kept asking the same fucking question.
so Saul only has a D as an example? Sounds shoehorned to me
not gunna argue, those were good arcs and to be honest they quenched my deep desire for power levels in some way. but i mean on broader terms.What are all of your favorite things about onepiece. Character design, overall goofyness, closeness of crew. Whatever,i see alot of arguing on here but everyone likes one piece
And that the initial D is inherited by every member of a family.
And more clearance that Garp isn't the only exception of being a D in the marines, which shows more a complex conflict over the World Government and Ds.
Also Robin's interest in D
You might not know it, since you're only in Arlong Park, wikifag. But Robin's flashback is where we find out most about the Ds up until that point from Saul. How it's not exclusive to people, how it's just a name passed down, how it's not some super special name that only super special people have like YOU seem to think.
>And a lot of people answered you.
yes they did answer. With circular reasoning. Saying Rouge needed a D FOR Ace when Ace didnt actually need a D isnt answering the question
I also asked several timeswhat would change if Rouge WASNT a D and NO one answered that one
>Also Robin's interest in D
I'm so hyped for Vivi and Dalton to mention their buddy Luffy, and have all the other leaders chime in how Luffy helped them and are his friends/supporters. Then the reaction to this by the WG, preferrably an oh shit what the fuck look, seeing how many are supportive of him. Luffy
Can you name examples of D that aren't "shoehorned" and explain why? Because we don't even know the entire purpose behind it.
Are you going to say Gol is shoehorned too? "uh to have a connection to the main character" or some shit?
>I also asked several timeswhat would change if Rouge WASNT a D and NO one answered that one
Maybe Roger wouldn't have given her the second one in that case, we have no idea so you can't say she didn't have it for a reason.
Not that she needs a reason. And not having a reason doesn't mean it is shoehorned in.
>if Rouge WASNT a D and NO one answered that one
You fucking retard. You just answered it in your fucking post. Because if she didn't have a D then Ace wouldn't have been using it. And why the fuck can't she have a D? Law's sister has a D, and either his mom or dad or both had one too, you double nigger. Are you gonna say that was shoehorned in too?
>believing 2chan spoilers
What the fuck would Jack be doing with a dream fruit when the last pages of 805 showed the town being destroyed with claw marks and large animal tracks?
>I also asked several timeswhat would change if Rouge WASNT a D and NO one answered that one
Plenty of people answered that you cocksnot.
>Ace wouldn't have taken "D" as a part of his name, like Law
>Rouge couldn't prolong her pregnancy by 11 months
>Garp probably wouldn't have helped her to begin with
>Can you name examples of D that aren't "shoehorned" and explain why?
Everyone that didnt die in the same chapter they were introduced since them being a D isnt necessary to the story
>nah I got all that from Law's flashback.
No you didn't you faggot. The thing that we found out in Law's flashback was that Ds were God's natural enemy, and CDs use to tell boogeyman stories about them. Guess you're getting your wiki knowledge all jumbled up in that braindead head of yours.
>stealing the soul from a skeleton with the soul fruit
The Marines, the lore, Zoro in general and the islands they visit due to how crazy they can be. Water 7 and Enies Lobby themselves because Venice and the hole, Jaya/Skypiea because sky and Punk Hazard because Hailfire Peaks.
>how it's just a name passed down, how it's not some super special name that only super special people have like YOU seem to think.
the not being exclusive to people thing never struck me as important. It's not like Saul being a giant changes anything
You still seem to think D is some special name only passed down to super relevant people. Saul showed us that's not the case. D is just a name passed down through generations like a last name. It just means their ancestors were part of the same tribe or whatever in the past.
>I also asked several timeswhat would change if Rouge WASNT a D and NO one answered that one
Then Ace wouldve been just Portgas Ace, since he wouldnt want to take anything from his father, and people wouldve called bullshit on Ace being Luffys brother from the very beginning since he wouldnt have shared any part of his name with Luffy.
Alternatively he still wouldve been called Portgas D Ace just to lead readers into thinking he and Luffy are indeed brothers, or at least half brothers since they share the D and Garps a D too, and the fact that hes taken a part of his fathers name despite explicitely stating that he took his mothers name and refused to acknowledge his father wouldve been a giant asspull.
>>Ace wouldn't have taken "D" as a part of his name, like Law
Why does this matter? It doesnt since he didnt ned a D. in his name to be a D.
>>Rouge couldn't prolong her pregnancy by 11 months
You have NO proof of this and need to back your claim up or stop trying to use it as an example
>>Garp probably wouldn't have helped her to begin with
you shouldn't add guesses when we already know Garp helped her because Roger asked him to
>Dalton is there
>Luffy is cool
>Wapol is there
>Fuck that guy
>the not being exclusive to people thing never struck me as important.
At that time we knew shit all about the D. Like you, a lot of people thought it was exlusive to maybe even Luffy's family. A lot of people theorized Luffy was a directly related to Roger because of this. Finding this out now seems irrelevant since you know more shit about the D BECAUSE of these little tidbits, but back then it solidified the fact that D was not an exclusive thing to Luffy's line, heck not even to humans. It was more like a last name type of deal, which we didn't have a concrete confirmation to until then either.
>Then Ace wouldve been just Portgas Ace, since he wouldnt want to take anything from his father, and people wouldve called bullshit on Ace being Luffys brother
This is madeup bullshit and you know it. No one would ever think to question that
>Alternatively he still wouldve been called Portgas D Ace just to lead readers into thinking he and Luffy are indeed brothers, or at least half brothers since they share the D and Garps a D too
I think you're just putting importance and what-if scenarios that you'll never be able to test and prove
>asking for what-ifs
>bitches when he gets what-if scenarios
it IS shoehorning. She didnt NEED a D as Ace being a D would have been brought to the forfront anyway
It's only forced onto her for Ace and has no bearing on anything else. Ace(again) not even NEEDING a D IN his name
Then why do you talk like you do? Saying people with Ds are shoehorned in implies that you think people with Ds need to be a super relevant people in the first place, which Oda already showed is not the case with Saul both explicitly in text and through the character himself.
>This is madeup bullshit and you know it. No one would ever think to question that
Yeah they would.
Gol D Roger was the only other D at that point in the story before Ace's appearance
>nami being a redhead is shoehorning because she didn't NEED red hair
that's how stupid you sound
>Ace(again) not even NEEDING a D IN his name
Then what would his connection to Luffy have been? It was just as shocking to find out Luffy and Ace weren't blood related at all. That was part of the twist too.
>Like you, a lot of people thought it was exlusive to maybe even Luffy's family
I never stated this.
>Finding this out now seems irrelevant since you know more shit about the D
which is why I dont see it as important. And looking back, it still really isnt
>it IS shoehorning.
No, you are using that word wrong. You'd just have to look in any dictionary or thesaurus.
>She didnt NEED a D
You don't know that Roger would have given her the second D if she wasn't one herself.
>Ace being a D would have been brought to the forfront anyway
Ace being a D. isn't relevant either. Being a D. is a corollary of what arguably made him plot important, but it wasn't important on its own.
>>asking for what-ifs
no im not?
you have no argument apparently
>Saying people with Ds are shoehorned in implies that you think people with Ds need to be a super relevant people in the first place
False. They dont have to be relevant to have a REASON beyond 'because another character needs them to be one'
>Gol D Roger was the only other D at that point in the story before Ace's appearance
that has nothing to do with people questioning if Ace and Luffy are ACTUALLY siblings. It's never even brought up unless Luffy brings it up
>which is why I dont see it as important.
Are you fucking retarded? The only reason we know all this shit in the first place is because of those scenes. Where the fuck do you think your precious wiki information comes from, you retard? The fucking manga. Holy shit, at this point I hope you really are just trolling.
Nami's hair color isnt important to anything. Nice deflection though
>Then what would his connection to Luffy have been?
That they SAID they were brothers? Him having the D is clearly fluff(provided by Rouge) when it wasnt necessary because he already IS a D
>>asking for what-ifs
no im not?
>I also asked several times what would change if Rouge WASNT a D and NO one answered that one
>I also asked several times what would change if
> what would change if
>No, you are using that word wrong. You'd just have to look in any dictionary or thesaurus.
oh it's you again
>You don't know that Roger would have given her the second D if she wasn't one herself.
what the fuck are you talking about? I swear, I always catch the non-english natives
>Being a D. is a corollary of what arguably made him plot important
Ace was plot important because he's the main character's brother
>that has nothing to do with people questioning if Ace and Luffy are ACTUALLY siblings. It's never even brought up unless Luffy brings it up
You do know that original argument was talking about the readers, right? Not the people in the manga. The whole "Ace needs a D to make the brothers story work" isnt about other fictional characters believing the story.
Or are you actually, for real, literally this dense?
>Monkey D. Luffy
Because unlike retarded niggers like you, people would've already been assuming they weren't blood related because of the name. The middle initial D gave them that connection that made us all kind of look the other way or not really question it for a while until the reveal. A lot of shit is obviously already spoiled for you already, but when you know little to nothing going through this, it's exciting to find these things out little by little, and not really expecting shit until the reveal hits.
>Sanji, Nami, Chopper and Brook are out again
>because they had that much spotlight in the last arc already
yeah somehow I don't believe it and if it's really true Oda seriously droped the ball on this one
>what is a rhetorical question
you literally have to make shit up to have an argument then dont even make up anything plausible/coherent
>You do know that original argument was talking about the readers, right?
yes I get that. Can you actually provide proof of people questioning that before the reveal?
Reminder that Apoo is from Tena Gena Kingdom,not sure if it's given.
>oh it's you again
Because more than one person can't call you out for not knowing the meaning of a word?
>what the fuck are you talking about? I swear, I always catch the non-english natives
I'm saying Roger and Rouge being lovers might have something to do with them both being D's.
>Ace was plot important because he's the main character's brother
Then in that case he didn't need to be a D. at all, yet you seem to have no problem with it.
>Because more than one person can't call you out for not knowing the meaning of a word?
please define what you THINK shoehorning is so I can correct you, spain-anon
>I'm saying Roger and Rouge being lovers might have something to do with them both being D's.
then Ace wouldn't take the D. in his name, would he?
>Then in that case he didn't need to be a D.
If you actually FOLLOW the argument taking place, you'd see that i've already said multiple times that he does not, in fact, need a D.
Ah, the chapter release must be coming closer. Half the thread is people arguing with some really pathetic individual and his poor trolling attempts.
Stupidity seems to increase exponetially the closer we get to a new chapter. We might hit critical mass soon.
I like wind and shockwaves, can't wait for more Dragon.
>please define what you THINK shoehorning is so I can correct you, spain-anon
Shoehorning is to force something where it doesn't fit, it is not a synonym for unnecessary or without reason.
>then Ace wouldn't take the D. in his name, would he?
No, he wouldn't exist. Jesus you can't be this retarded.
>in fact, need a D.
I'm not talking about his name.
>Shoehorning is to force something where it doesn't fit
Forcing a D where it doesnt fit isnt shoehorning?
>No, he wouldn't exist. Jesus you can't be this retarded.
He'd exist as Portgas Ace. Roger is still a D. whether Rouge has the D. or not. Ace not taking his father's initial doesnt make him suddenly not a D.
>I'm not talking about his name.
As in Roger isnt a D.? Sure, why not? He could just be another too powerful fucker in the New World.
failed his 13 year old goal. Imagine spending 13 years trying to achieve something for someone extremely important in your life, and then coming to the realization that you weren't able to fucking do it. Because no matter how much you put into it and risked your ass for it, some bullshit thing happens (strings stitching), and now you lost the opportunity cause you're gonna die.
where in the story does it fit that even matters? Not having a D in her name changes maybe a single line of dialogue
>you dont even know why ace had a D.?
where did I imply that?
>Forcing a D where it doesnt fit isnt shoehorning?
Why doesn't it fit and how is it forced? Don't say it's because nothing would change (you don't know that, but that's not what I'm arguing anyway) or it is unnecessary.
>He'd exist as Portgas Ace.
If his parents weren't lovers he wouldn't exist based on that predication.
>As in Roger isnt a D.? Sure, why not? He could just be another too powerful fucker in the New World.
I asked you something along the lines of why you aren't arguing that Ace being a D. is forced. Stop derailing questions so far.
>ok, so do you know what the letter D. stands for? and its importance to the story?
so you're bringing up something irrelevant to the argument? Okay. Just a reminder, we're talking about how Rouge didnt need a D at all and was therefore, shoehorned onto her
Spoiler confirmed by redon
- Nightmare Rain
- Luffy arrives at the top of a hill along the minkmen
- A old giraffe minkman explains luffy that he'll tell him about Sanji if he can beat him
- Luffy punches him before he can finish his sentence and the minkman passes out
- Law and Robin find Bepo, penguin and shachi
- Zoro, Franky and Usopp are trying to find Luffy on their own and meet a snake minkman
- After the giraffe minkman wakes up he explains that the foreign king Tin-Plate ate "the tanuki and his subordinates"
>we're talking about how Rouge didnt need a D
Except there is at least one reason why she might've needed it (not her technically, just Ace's mother). And at least start changing your conclusion to her initial being unnecessary instead of shoehorned, it's embarrassing having to read it so often.
>we're talking about how Rouge didnt need a D at all and was therefore, shoehorned onto her
we know hardly anything about here, who are you to judge that it was shoehorned onto her. her behaviour was totally "D. worthy"
>Why doesn't it fit and how is it forced?
>But don't say why it doesnt fit and how it was forced
Rouge being a D, affects nothing. Nothing at all. Without her, Ace would STILL be a D.
>If his parents weren't lovers he wouldn't exist based on that predication.
OR he'd be a D. that just doesnt tell people the D. part when asked. aka Portgas Ace. Because Roger is still a D regardless of what Rouge is
>why you aren't arguing that Ace being a D. is forced.
Because Roger, the reason anyone even cares about the D. is his father? He literally came out of Roger's balls. Ace is genetic and Rouge is just because IE shoehorned in. If Roger WASNT a D then there wouldnt even BE an argument
because Roger already had one
>Except there is at least one reason why she might've needed it
the ONLY reason she needed it was so Ace could have it which was never actually shoeho- I mean necessary
I dont see why I should not say shoehorned when i'm using it correctly
>her behaviour was totally "D. worthy"
Unless you have proof her being pregnant so long was a D. thing, i'd stop trying to use that as evidence
Best pairing! Incredible chemistry in the manga and great doujins!
>Rouge being a D, affects nothing. Nothing at all. Without her, Ace would STILL be a D.
Where was it said that you only need one parent to get the initial in your name>
Saul said everybody in his family had "D". So did Law. Roger falling in love or wanting to breed with another D also follows this rule.
>Rouge being a D, affects nothing. Nothing at all. Without her, Ace would STILL be a D.
except without her being a D, ace would be dead now, she held him in for so long with the will of the D so that she could hide him from the marine for long enough for them to think he choldnt be rogers son which they were looking for.
she's not just the mother of ace. she's her own charakter. and not just meant to pass on a name to her kid that he'd have anyway.
you talk like two people having black her shouldnt have kdis because black her is dominant so the ones parents hair color doesnt even affect anything so its shoehorned.
Guys don't you think Zou being an elephant was shoehorned in?
Minks are also shoehorned in.
You know what else was shoehorned in?
The Tenryuubito. Nothing before they randomly showed had any indication they existed!
It's not about being worthy, it's inheritance.
>the ONLY reason she needed it was so Ace could have it
No, that is ONE confirmed reason that she needed to have it in her name. You haven't even considered the possibility that there would be no relationship between Roger and Rouge if they both weren't D's.
Ignore the wikireader, here's some more elaborated spoilers from >>133133281
Coverstory: On the decks around the world ~The man with the 500 Mio. Berri~ vol.1: Luffy's home, the Fusha Village
- Usopp uses "pop green - booty banana" to rescue everyone from the coming flood
- Luffy and co. are hit by the flood as well, but Wany (Wanda's crocodile) carries them through the river
- they get to a place with an altar
- when Luffy and Bepo climb onto the altar, they find the bodies of Sanji and the others
- after Sanji and the others arrived at the whale forest by night, they seem to have been taken their souls by the god of that forest
- according to Carrot, it's also as if they already died
- Robin checks the circumstances of the devastated town
- it seems that the user of the yume yume no mi (yume = dream), Jack, was the one who created an illusion, a dreamworld, with a technique called "dream jack" that feigns the town to be destroyed
- any tools to avoid being hit by sleepwalking were useless, so the guardians had no other choice but to fight all night long
- Luffy wants to meet with the god of the forest
Are you another shitposter or does Redon frequent a site I don't know about because there's nothing about this on AP or his spic forum
>You haven't even considered the possibility that there would be no relationship between Roger and Rouge if they both weren't D's.
Let's not bring your headcanon into this. Unless you can prove both if Law's parents were born Ds and not just married into it
for fucks sake, i shouldn't be spoonfeeding this idiot but i have nothing better to do
He could have meant immediate family or it could be a subtle allusion to D's liking to spread their genes amongst themselves.
It isn't my headcanon (I don't know if I believe it), it's a possibility. Until you can prove it isn't a possibility you can't claim Rouge has no other reasons for being a D.
i'll be waiting with
help me out here, i'm looking for the part that says being a D. is what let her be pregnant for 20 months
Because all IM seeing is Sengoku commending her sheer willpower
you post alot of 'could have's and 'possibly's but nothing to back it up
I want Bellamy to be my lewd boy slave.
>you post alot of 'could have's and 'possibly's but nothing to back it up
Read the last part of that post. I'm not saying either way, but you seem convinced that Rouge has no other reasons for being a D. so you should be able to disprove these fairly reasonable possibilities.
STOP WITH THIS BULLSHIT ABOUT ACE REEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>but you seem convinced that Rouge has no other reasons for being a D
until Oda GIVES her another reason, she DOESNT have another reason. Canonically, she's a D for the sake of giving Ace a D. in his middle name.
It says family LINE there you moron
that means... children born into the family get the D. initial, not that everyone in the family has it. People married IN to the family obviously get it that way and arent necessarily D.s to begin with
>help me out here, i'm looking for the part that says being a D. is what let her be pregnant for 20 months
It's obvious that's the reason why
It's like asking to prove that being a D has anything to do with Luffy hearing the voice of all things
at this point, bonney could just have a connection to anyone really
he's already tried, he justs gets distracted by something shiny and never gets any work done
Apoo straight up hypnotized him at Shabondy. Dedicated effort is just not his forte