Which of these two character designs do you prefer and why?
A I like warrior chicks but I'd probably like Zarya better without the dumb hair and tats.
>left looks stupid all over, like some Westerner trying to imitate bad Eastern character design (why the fuck does the bow need a shitty chakram attached to it, what use is a shitty 3/4 spear?)
>meanwhile on the right, let's make this armoured heavy gunner but hurr no armour on the arms and head (where you're most likely to get hit) to show off this dyed butch haircut and tattoos aren't we progressive?
TLDR they're both fucking dumb.
Left looks like an old school healthy woman good to carry quite some offspring. Right looks like a dyke, in other words a waste of organic matter, especially given the pink hair and the tattoo (poor judgment) and the scar on the face (reckless and unable to defend herself where it's most needed)
B is better character design, the only reason i could see people liking A more is waifuism. A seriously looks like someone in high school drew it, why did they go with this art style?
Phoebe is fat! FAT!
and so is Zarya!
Seems to fit her trope more than A
More detailed, note facial expression and outfit
Not a fat sack of shit
This is all ignoring that I don't really play or like spessmarine games.
she's a racist cunt that spews toxic comments behind everyones' backs and she drove my mother to suicide. If I ever let myself get as old as she has I'd be eating a bullet happily, that isn't living.
They'd both be perfect if they just had bigger boobs. God, I wish they made women like this in real life, but it's physically impossible without Non-Klinefelter XXY or juicing, both of which completely ruin your feminine qualities.
Why does B have long legs and short arms? it's like lanky kong but reversed.
>mfw B was created to pander to SJWs but all they did was whine that she's a male with tits when she was announced.
There's a lot of real detail and anatomy in B, but it is cartoony enough to avoid any kind of uncanny valley type feel, and it generally looks awesome. It looks like an awesome comic book character.
A looks like the cartoon version of an awesome comic book character. Where they cut a whole lot of details so it'd be easier to animate. It doesn't really look bad, but honestly, it looks like that face is just floating in a blob, while B has some nice bone structure adding to a shaped face.
In other words, B looks like Savage Dragon drawn by Erik Larsen for a comic book, and A looks like Savage Dragon drawn cheaply for the cartoon.
Who the fuck has shins that short and fat that is not deformed? Is she supposed to be a female dwarf? Why does she have a muscular upper body and an obese woman's legs?
Just looks like a man with pink hair, homos will fap to it, tumblrinas will applaud it's non traditional gender roles.
Who exactly is this shit supposed to appeal to? Fetishists and tumblrinas? Surely that is not a big enough market to bank on?
>a female doesn't look like this
Why are muscle girls so great?
Fuck off SJWs and tumblr fags
Honestly it's fucking ugly and a clusterfuck. It doesn't have a real anatomy in it's design, it's legs are too long and arms are too short. The pink hair is also a generic (One of most commonly used) hair colour for special snowflake heroines. Also, the hair style looks really unappealing and gross.
Learn to look at real art, not deviantart shit.
You guys are proving what I'm saying? Neither of those girls look like what the OP posted.
Here, a 5 min sketch to show a realistic female body builder
here's a better pic
A, because B is literally a man with tits.
I have no problem with the pink hair tumblrshit since I'll never play the game, I'll never play either but that is seriously lazy character design.
Only Samoan women are aloud to be built like that
>Actually thinking yours makes sense even though i didn't quote you
>B is worse because of reason listed here >>315359526
>A is obliviously better because it's well portioned and has a good simple design
>Thinking B is better because muh stronk woyam with generic pink heroine hair and special snowflake shit
Compare ronda's arms or shoulders to OP's pic.
Women don't magically become stocky and thick like that just because they're muscular.
A looks like they wanted a muscle girl but then decided to give up halfway.
A. The hair and scar are a much better fit and the dumb bow is superior to the dumb future gun. There are multiple visible scars instead of just a dumb anime cross scar. The armor is pretty skimpy but the gaps just show off muscles and the whole thing looks Herculean.
Also, she's smiling.
Stay in your board.
Left is trash, because an actual trained warrior won't be fat, least of all an Amazon who by being of Greek origin wouldn't be fat since ages bee constantly training and fighting.
Cut off a tit too, because otherwise you appropriate amazon culture
Right is bulky but hey body armor and a gun.
Zarya. Her design is average, not bad but not great. On a personal note I don't care for the hair color but whatever.
The other girl however is flat out bad design; like R. Mika bad.
The left, if only because the silhouette on the right design is baffling. Why would you create a character that totes around a giant gun like that and not give them a top-heavy form? It worked perfectly for the Heavy in TF2, are Blizzard's designers just that incompetent? She is all leg when she should be more arm. On top of that she gets a suit that doesn't complement the gun, a tattoo that won't ever been seen, and a haircut that could have been used to fix her shitty bottom-heavy silhouette.
The girl on the left wasn't built for that weapon. I don't hate that design compared to the one on the right but it could use some work as well.
>an Amazon isn't built for bow and spear
Whats your point?
I agree B is shit but still most of their design being their outfit isn't an inherently bad thing.
proportions can be purposely stylized, I bet you think Dragon's Crown looks like shit too.
>I hate pink hair
that isnt a legitimate argument against other people's opinions.
I think they both look like shit too, but your arguments dont make sense and your shit's all retarded.
No she don't.
That's an issue with Lady Athletes, a lot of the time they end up killing a lot of body fat which kills a lot of what we deem the feminine figure. Some can still end up cutting a nice figure though, with the help of surgery mostly.
But sometimes you get lucky freaks...or good photoshoppers.
It's sad that she hates that everyone likes that she's adorable.
However neither Zarya or Purplebarian are anymore realistic than a Frank Cho pin up.
Is B a dude or a chick?
...going with A as the better design, I can tell what she is with no effort. Fat female archer.
Whereas B I'm not sure what it is, just that it's human and has what seems to be a laser gun or something.
Maybe A's legs are just one thick giant muscle?
i'd like B more if she was in full power armor rather than exposing her arms.
a helmet would be cool too. it'd be novel if she were the huge mcbuff spess soldier just as a big stronk woman
B looks much better in game. A has several problems and a more uninspired design. B wins easy
You could fix A if you changed that shit hair color to something natural, remade the armor to look better, and proportioned the body to be more feminine and realistic.
B easily. Better proportions, better armor design and more detail in general. A looks like its proportions are off. Be it too long limbs, too short of a torso or too wide. Even the muscular arms and fat legs look super weird.