Would bacon made from the Tepig line taste spicy or can just never cool down once you cook it?
Personally, the way I cooked it, it had a lovely kick of cayenne and several other herbs and spices. My point is this WILL kick the back of your throat, no question. However, there's a delectable "Savoury" flavor amongst the undertones of "Sweet and Salty". You sir, have to cook like a master in order to obtain the level of taste I'm talking about.
All pokemon would taste somewhat the same. Imagine Pokemon as a single species; such as the Canidae or Feline family. So a pig pokemon would have roughly the same genetics as Magikarp, but the pokemon themselves look and behave drastically different.
Also being the same species allows them to communicate with each other, and yet humans tend to have difficulty understanding them.